Ben & Jerry’s Peanut Butter Half Baked Non-Dairy Ice Cream

This Ben & Jerry's flavor was among the top five overall winners of our entire plant-based ice cream taste test. It's so intense it's like eating half-baked brownies and Reeces coated in ice cream — all our favorite tastes rolled together.

Quick health facts: The pint has 990 calories and each serving has 43 grams of carbs or 27 added grams of sugar. That's 9 teaspoons. But then again... YOLO!

Where to find it: Wherever there’s a freezer case. Ben & Jerry’s is a ubiquitous brand in the ice cream aisle and retails for around $5 a pint.